Homes, values and local insight for Anna Maria, Manatee County, Florida. Typical home value $1,876,000.
Reviewed and updated October 3, 2026 by Ryan and Megan Winslow, Winslow Homes
Live listings open in a new tab, highest price first. Or type exactly what you want in the search bar.
Anna Maria Island is an exclusive barrier island off Manatee County's coast, home to one of Florida's most desirable and expensive real estate markets. The small island community (population ~1,500) features pristine Gulf beaches, upscale residential properties, and a laid-back island atmosphere. Island culture emphasizes preservation, limiting commercial development. Strong environmental stewardship protects natural resources and maintains island character. Considered one of Florida's best beach destinations.
Anna Maria Island real estate focuses on beachfront and near-beach properties with premium pricing reflecting location. Properties range from modest beach cottages to multimillion-dollar estates. Waterfront properties dominate value. Limited inventory and strong buyer demand support consistent appreciation. Buyers include wealthy retirees, investors, and second-home owners seeking exclusive beach living. Seasonal appreciation from snowbirds seeking winter escapes.
Winslow Homes serves Anna Maria buyers and sellers across FL, MA, CT, and RI. Ryan and Megan Winslow provide both brokerage and mortgage services (Ryan Winslow NMLS #2426605 | Megan Winslow NMLS #2692933). Get pre-approved at www.winslowloan.com or call 386-690-5858.
Direct Gulf beachfront homes with sand access, sunset views, and water recreation. Premium pricing. Most exclusive properties.
Price Range: $1,200,000 - $3,000,000
Properties within walking distance of beaches. Beach access but without direct waterfront. Still premium pricing.
Price Range: $550,000 - $1,200,000
Island properties not directly beachfront. Still premium compared to mainland. Island community appeal.
Price Range: $400,000 - $800,000
Bay and canal front properties with boat access. Water views without direct Gulf front. Strong appeal for boating enthusiasts.
Price Range: $600,000 - $1,500,000
Condominium buildings with beachfront or near-beach locations. Lower entry price than single-family. Rental potential.
Price Range: $300,000 - $900,000
Swimming, shelling, paddleboarding, beach walks. Sand access central to lifestyle. Daily beach culture.
Boating, fishing, kayaking. Protected bay and Gulf access. Excellent for water enthusiasts.
Waterfront restaurants, beach bars, local shops. Casual island atmosphere. Strong seasonal activity.
Beach nesting turtles, bird sanctuaries, natural preservation. Eco-conscious community.
Pristine Gulf beaches with white sand. Swimming, shelling, sunbathing. Daily focal point of island life.
Iconic fishing pier with sunset views. Gathering place. Excellent fishing and photography location.
Casual island dining with Gulf views. Fresh seafood. Beach bar atmosphere. Iconic local gathering spots.
Buy beachfront or near-beach, rent to seasonal tourists. 8-12% gross yields common. Winter season demand strong.
Water properties appreciate 6-8% annually. Limited supply supports consistent values. Minimal effort required.
Buy condos, convert to vacation rentals. Generate 6-10% cash returns. Turnkey investment.
The typical home in Anna Maria is worth $1,876,000, 360% above the Manatee County typical value of $408,000 and 400% above the Florida typical value of $375,000.
Zillow Home Value Index for Anna Maria, August 2026. The middle of the market for single family homes and condos.
Home values in Anna Maria moved +11.8% over five years and +105.6% over ten.
Share of occupied homes in Anna Maria lived in by the owner.
Older homes often need inspection focus on roof, systems and windows.
Median household income in Anna Maria.
Median age of residents in Anna Maria.
Ryan and Megan are mortgage bankers with The Federal Savings Bank, lending in all 50 states. You get the home and the loan from one team. On a typical Anna Maria home of $1,876,000:
Ryan and Megan price Anna Maria homes from recent sales, not guesses. Send your address and you get a free market analysis, with no obligation.
Typical value $989,000 · 3,049 residents
Area guide →Typical value $628,000 · 927 residents
Area guide →Typical value $350,000 · 13,682 residents
Area guide →Typical value $353,000 · 58,184 residents
Area guide →Typical value $948,000 · 7,463 residents
Area guide →8,730 residents
Area guide →See the full Manatee County real estate guide or the Florida real estate guide.
The Zillow Home Value Index for Anna Maria was $1,876,000 in August 2026, -2.2% over the past year.
Anna Maria is in Manatee County, Florida.
About 1,016 people as of the 2024 Census Bureau estimate, up from 968 in 2020.
Ryan and Megan Winslow of Winslow Homes have sold over 3,000 homes since 2009 and are licensed in Florida, Massachusetts, Connecticut and Rhode Island. Call or text 386-690-5858.
Apply at www.winslowloan.com. Ryan and Megan are mortgage bankers with The Federal Savings Bank and lend in all 50 states, including FHA, VA and conventional loans.
95% of occupied homes in Anna Maria are owner occupied, based on the 2019 to 2023 American Community Survey.
17 years, over 3,000 homes sold, and one team for the home and the loan. Call or text 386-690-5858.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau 2024 population estimates and 2019 to 2023 American Community Survey; Zillow Home Value Index, August 2026. Numbers update as new data is released. Talk to Ryan and Megan for current sold prices on your street.
No in-person meeting or phone call needed for most addresses. See your estimated value, price range and value trend in seconds.
Get coming-soon homes, pocket listings and price drops in Anna Maria, FL before they hit the big home search sites.
The typical home in Anna Maria is worth $1,876,779 as of August 2026 in ZIP code 34216. Values moved -2.2% over the last 12 months at the middle ZIP code.
| ZIP | Typical value | 12 months | 5 years | Median sale, Mar to May 2026 | Days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 34216 | $1,876,779 | -2.2% | +11.6% | $1,791,250 | 75 |
Sources: Zillow Home Value Index through August 2026 and the Redfin Data Center ZIP code tracker, March to May 2026. Ask Ryan and Megan for a value for your own home.
